Skip to main navigation menu Skip to main content Skip to site footer
Galilæana. Studies in Renaissance and Early Modern Science

Essays

Vol. 22 No. 1 (2025)

An early theological application of Galileo’s “doctrine” of motion: Insights from Benedetto Castelli’s first letter to Galileo (April 1, 1607)

  • Ivan Malara
DOI
https://doi.org/10.57617/gal-69
Submitted
15 October 2024
Published
2025-04-29

Abstract

In 1607, Benedetto Castelli sent a letter to Galileo Galilei from Cava de’ Tirreni. This correspondence provides valuable insights into Castelli’s mathematical training and is significant for two main reasons. First, it demonstrates that by 1607, Galileo had already articulated key principles of his scientific work, such as the relativity of motion and a concept resembling inertia. Thus, the letter serves as an important source on Galileo’s advanced thinking prior to the publication of Sidereus Nuncius (1610). Second, it explores the relationship between Galileo’s ideas on motion, the eternity of the world, and the existence of God. Castelli refutes Aristotelian errors and underscores the limitations of Galilean science regarding theological matters, aiming to prevent conflicts between scientific inquiry and religious truths. This letter thus highlights the early debates sparked by Galileo’s new “doctrine” of motion, occurring before any of his major findings were published.

References

  1. Abbreviations
  2. OG = Galilei, Galileo. Opere. National Edition, edited by Antonio Favaro, 20 vols. Firenze: Barbèra, 1890-1909.
  3. OGA = Galilei, Galileo. Opere. Appendix to the National Edition, edited by M. Camerota et al., 4 vols. Firenze: Giunti Editore, 2013-2019.
  4. Manuscript sources
  5. APUG = Archivio Storico della Pontificia Università Gregoriana
  6. Sources
  7. Archimedes. De iis quae vehuntur in aqua libri duo a Federico Commandino Urbinate in pristinum nitorem restituti, et commentariis illustrati. Bononiae: ex Officina Alexandri Benacii, 1565.
  8. Aristotle. De physico audito libri octo. Cum Averrois Cordubensis variis in eosdem commentariis. Venetiis: apud Iunctas, 1562.
  9. Castelli, Benedetto. Carteggio, edited by Massimo Bucciantini. Firenze: Olschki, 1998.
  10. Conimbricenses. In octo libros Physicorum Aristotelis Stagyritae. Conimbricae: typis et expensis Antonij a Mariz Universitatis Typographi, 1592.
  11. Galilei, Galileo. On Motion and On Mechanics. Comprising De Motu (ca. 1590), translated with Introduction and Notes by I.E. Drabkin, and Le Meccaniche (ca. 1600), translated with introduction and notes by S. Drake. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press, 1960.
  12. Galilei, Galileo. Galileo against the Philosophers, translated by S. Drake. Los Angeles: Zeitlin & Ver Brugge, 1976.
  13. Galilei, Galileo. Operations of the Geometric and Military Compass, 1606, translated with an introduction by Stillman Drake. Washington: Dibner library of the history of science and technology, 1978.
  14. Galilei, Galileo. Tractatio De Praecognitionibus et Praecognitis and Tractatio De Demonstratione, transcribed from the Latin autograph by William F. Edwards; with an introduction, notes and commentary by William A. Wallace. Padova: Antenore, 1988.
  15. Galilei, Galileo. Dialogo sopra i due massimi sistemi del mondo tolemaico e copernicano, edited and commented by Ottavio Besomi and Mario Otto Helbing, 2 vols. Padova: Antenore, 1998.
  16. Galilei, Galileo. Le mecaniche, edited by Romano Gatto. Firenze: Olschki, 2002.
  17. Galilei, Galileo. Due lezioni dell’Accademia Fiorentina circa la figura, sito e grandezza dell’Inferno di Dante, edited by Riccardo Pratesi. Livorno: Sillabe, 2011.
  18. Galilei, Galileo and Christopher Scheiner. On Sunspots, edited and translated by Eileen Reeves and Albert Van Hallen. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 2010.
  19. Perera, Benet. De communibus omnium rerum naturalium principijs et affectionibus libri quindecim. Romae: impensis Venturini Tramezini, 1576.
  20. Ptolemy, Claudius. Almagestum seu Magnae Contructionis Mathematicae Opus plane divinum Latina donatum lingua ab Georgio Trapezuntio usquequaque doctissimo. Per Lucam Gauricum Neapolitanum divinae matheseos professorem egregium in alma urbe Veneta orbis regina recognitum. Venetiis: Luceantonii Iunta officina, 1528.
  21. Thomas Aquinas. Summa theologiae. Romae: In aedibus populi Romani apud Georgium Ferrarium, 1587.
  22. Zabarella, Jacopo. In libros Aristotelis physicorum commentarii. Venetiis: apud Iohannem Antonium et Iacobum de Franciscis, et Franciscum Bolzetam, 1601.
  23. Studies
  24. Biagioli, Mario. Galileo’s Instruments of Credit: Telescopes, Images, Secrecy. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2006. https://doi.org/10.7208/chicago/9780226045634.001.0001
  25. Bucciantini, Massimo. “Atomi geometria e teologia nella filosofia galileiana di Benedetto Castelli”. In Geometria e atomismo nella scuola galileiana, edited by Massimo Bucciantini and Maurizio Torrini, 171-191. Firenze: Olschki, 1992.
  26. Bucciantini, Massimo. Galileo e Keplero. Filosofia, cosmologia e teologia nell’età della Controriforma. Torino: Einaudi, 2003.
  27. Büttner, Jochen. Swinging and Rolling. Unveiling Galileo’s Unorthodox Path from a Challenging Problem to a New Science. Cham: Springer, 2019.
  28. Camerota, Michele. Galileo Galilei e la cultura scientifica nell’età della Controriforma. Roma: Salerno, 2004.
  29. Cardoso, Wlamir Thomazi and Roberto de Andrade Martins. “O Trattato della Sfera ovvero Cosmografia de Galileo Galilei e algumas Cosmografias e Tratados da Esfera do Século XVI”. Episteme 13, (2008), 15- 38.
  30. Cardoso, Wlamir Thomazi and Roberto de Andrade Martins. “Galileo’s Trattato della sfera ovvero cosmografia and Its Sources”. Philosophia Scientiae 21 (2017), 131-147. https://doi.org/10.4000/philosophiascientiae.1248
  31. Clavelin, Maurice. “Le copernicanisme Padouan de Galilée”. In Tribute to Galileo in Padua. International Symposium, 149-166. Trieste: LINT, 1995.
  32. Cosci, Matteo. “Astronomia pavana nel Dialogo de Cecco di Ronchitti da Bruzene in perpuosito de la stella nuova tra commedia, satira, disputatio accademica e poesia”. In I generi dell’aristotelismo volgare nel Rinascimento, edited by Marco Sgarbi, 125-187. Padova: Cleup, 2018.
  33. Cosci, Matteo. “Galileo alias Astolfo Arnerio Marchiano e la disputa padovana sulla Stella Nuova”. In Atti e Memorie dell’Accademia Galileiana di Scienze, Lettere ed Arti di Padova, 35-83. Padova: Presso la sede dell’Accademia, 2020.
  34. Cosci, Matteo. “Galileo alias Alimberto Mauri e la disputa fiorentina sulla Stella Nuova”. In Atti e Memorie dell’Accademia Galileiana di Scienze, Lettere ed Arti di Padova, 111-148. Padova: Presso la sede dell’Accademia, 2023.
  35. Craig, William Lane. The Cosmological Argument from Plato to Leibniz. London: The Macmillan press, 1980.
  36. De Andrade Martins, Roberto. “Galileo Galilei, los climas, y la tradición del Tractatus de sphaera de Johannes de Sacrobosco”. In Epistemología e Historia de la Ciencia, edited by Pío García and Alba Massolo, 373-380. Córdoba: Universidad Nacional de Córdoba, 2010.
  37. Drake, Stillman. Galileo Studies: Personality, Tradition, and Revolution. Ann Arbor: The University of Michigan Press, 1970. https://doi.org/10.1163/221058777X00056
  38. Drake, Stillman. “Castelli, Benedetto”. In Dictionary of Scientific Biography, edited by Charles Coulston Gillispie, vol. III, 115-117. New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons, 1971.
  39. Drake, Stillman. “Tartaglia’s Squadra and Galileo’s Compasso”. Annali dell’Istituto e Museo di Storia della Scienza di Firenze, 2 (1977), 35-54.
  40. Drake, Stillman. Galileo at Work. His Scientific Biography. Chicago-London: The University of Chicago Press, 1978.
  41. Favaro, Antonio. “Galileo Galilei ed il «Dialogo de Cecco di Ronchitti da Bruzene in perpuosito de la stella nova»”. Atti del Reale Istituto veneto di scienze, lettere ed arti, 7 (1881), 195-276.
  42. Favaro, Antonio. Galileo Galilei e lo Studio di Padova, 2 vols. Padova: Antenore, 1966.
  43. Giudice, Franco. “Galileo’s Cosmological View from the Sidereus Nuncius to Letters on Sunspots”. Galilaeana, 11 (2014), 49-63.
  44. Howell, Kenneth J. God’s Two Books. Copernican Cosmology and Biblical Interpretation in Early Modern Science. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press, 2002.
  45. Koyré, Alexandre. Etudes Galiléennes. Paris: Hermann, 1966.
  46. Masetti Zannini, Gian Lodovico. La vita di Benedetto Castelli. Brescia: Industria e Agricoltura di Brescia della Associazione industriale bresciana, 1961.
  47. Mattei Cerasoli, Leone. “La badia della SS. Trinità di Cava”. In L’Italia benedettina, 153-227. Roma: Ferrari 1929.
  48. Mottana, Annibale. Galileo e la bilancetta. Un momento fondamentale nella storia dell’idrostatica e del peso specifico. Firenze: Olschki, 2017.
  49. Piccinali, Luca. “La formazione scientifica di Benedetto Castelli tra Brescia e Padova (1578-1610)” (MA thesis, Università degli Studi di Trento-Università degli Studi di Verona, 2018).
  50. Piccinali, Luca. “La famiglia di Benedetto Castelli. Note dalle polizze d’estimo bresciane (1517-1627)”. Galilaeana 16 (2019), 133-146.
  51. Redondi, Pietro. “From Galileo to Augustine”. In The Cambridge Companion to Galileo Galilei, edited by Peter Machamer, 175-210. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1998. https://doi.org/10.1017/CCOL0521581788.006
  52. Redondi, Pietro. “Natura e Scrittura”. In Il caso Galileo: una rilettura storica, filosofica, teologica, edited by Massimo Bucciantini, Michele Camerota, and Franco Giudice, 153-162. Firenze: Olschki, 2011.
  53. Ricciardo, Salvatore. “Introduzione”. In Benedetto Castelli, Della misura delle acque correnti, Alcuni opuscoli filosofici, edited by Salvatore Ricciardo, 5-40. Brescia: Morcelliana, 2018.
  54. Shore, Steven N. “Castelli, Benedetto (Antonio)”. In Biographical Encyclopedia of Astronomers, edited by Thomas Hockey et al., 208-209. New York: Springer, 2007.
  55. Soppelsa, Maria Lura. Genesi del metodo galileiano e tramonto dell’aristotelismo nella scuola padovana. Padova: Antenore, 1974.
  56. Valleriani, Matteo. Galileo Engineer. New York: Springer, 2010. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-90-481-8645-7
  57. Wootton, David. Galileo: Watcher of the Skies. New Haven: Yale University Press, 2010.